25 April 2014

The Rokeby Venus

 The article that I found most interesting was "The Rokeby Venus" from March 10, 1914. In this article is the account of Mary Richardson who attempted to destroy the painting, the Venus Velasquez that hung in the National Gallery (CP 212). What I found most interesting is Richardson claims that her inspiration for having done this act was the arrest of Mrs. Pankhurst at Kensington (CP 212). Richardson's method was to hide an axe within her sleeve and she waited for the perfect moment to strike the picture. She did not wait until the gallery was closing or when it was empty, instead she planned this attack on the artwork in full-view of the gallery's guests. There were even security guards present which resulted in Richardson only being able to strike the glass a few times and not reach the actual print before she was tackled to the ground and removed.
  Security were not the only people to accost Richardson, visitors of the gallery did as well. Books were thrown at her by visitors and the entire commotion turned into a mob-attack (CP 214). Following this incident, Richardson was taken into questioning as security wanted to know if there were any other of her women in the gallery (CP 215). Her response, "Oh, I expect so" (CP 215). Even though it was a lie, Richardson's response was enough to set the entire gallery on edge; proving that during this era of suffragettes people feared the destruction that followed with these women.
  Some questions that I had when reading this article were:
    1) Why the Venus Velasquez?
         -Richardson mentions its high value and her dislike of the image but I wonder if there was an underlying reason as well.
     2) Were other artworks either destroyed or attempted to be destroyed by the suffragettes?
     3) Art often serves as a response to a political or social issue, is that why artwork was targeted?
     4) If Pankhurst had not been removed in Kensington would Richardson have been able to attack the artwork?
Thoughts?
Works Cited
Women in European History Coursepacket. Compiled by Shelley Wolbrink. Spring 2014.
Image from Google 

21 April 2014

Women and Children Coal Miners

  We have previously discussed the different occupations in which women found work in during the Industrial Revolution. Factories and mills were among the most common but one that is not most often thought of is mining. Now I don't know about the rest of you but I typically classify mining as a male profession but in the 19th century, women as well as children could be found working alongside men in the mines.
   According to several testimonies from workers at the South Wales Mine, the work was anything but a walk in the park. One woman even said that working in the mines would make a woman old by the age of 40 due to strenuous hauling of coal and workers in and out of the mines (The Coal Mines Industrial Revolution 1).
    Although women worked alongside men each had very different jobs. According to "The Coal Mines Industrial Revolution", "Teams of women were employed to use windlass to lift coal and workers. Men refused to do such work" (1). Even though both sexes had the goal of extracting coal in order for it be sold, men and women had different tasks. One aspect not mentioned in this article was what the tasks were that were specifically designated for men. Could it be like the handout Dr. Wolbrink provided us with today that said men could be overseers and supervisors while women did the "dirty work"? Were women the ones actually hauling the coal while men just monitored?
   An unbelievable fact that I found from this article was that children were employed to work in the mines. Anyone knows the dangers of working in a mine so why would one endanger the lives of children simply to make money? According to "The Coal Mines Industrial Revolution", "One six year old girl said 'I have been down six weeks and make 10 to 14 rakes a day; I carry a full 56 lbs. of coal in a wooden bucket. I work with sister Jesse and mother. It is dark the time we go" (1). As this quote shows, children were made to carry heavy loads back and forth into all hours of the night. As we saw in today's lecture, even children were exploited during the Industrial Revolution as the focus changed from health and well-being to money and progress.
    Some final questions for you all:
        -Do you think parents encouraged their children to work in such dangerous predicaments because they had no other choice, i.e. no one to watch the kids, or do you think the wages a child would bring home were the focus?
        -What jobs do you think men had in the mines compared to those of the women?
        -This article discussed that one girl was 6 when she began working, do you think children even younger than that were working in the mines?


Works Cited
"The Coal Mines Industrial Revolution." Women In World History. Last updated 2013. http://www.womeninworldhistory.com/coalMine.html.
All images from Google Images.

10 April 2014

Why are the books Pride and Prejudice and Sense and Sensibility so closely related?

  For this blog post I decided to go a different route than just focusing on either of the Austen novels. Instead I would like to discuss the strong similarities between the two novels Pride and Prejudice and Sense and Sensibility. While I have only read the novel Pride and Prejudice I had no idea what the movie Sense and Sensibility was going to be about. I was quite surprised that the storyline is very similar to that of Pride and Prejudice. There are several ways in which the books are similar:
   1-There are at least two sisters who are constantly being compared to one another
   2-There are love triangles galore
   3-Women struggle with financial issues
   4-Men have the upper-hand in society
On Wednesday we discussed that Austen based her writings off of her own life story and the time period in which she lived. I understand why the political and social issues are so similar in the books, being that they were only written two years apart from one another (Notes). What I question is why the comparison of two sisters and their problems with love are so similar? It almost seems as if Austen did not know how to write about anything else other than two or more sisters who are the complete opposites of one another and their struggles with the unbending ways of love. I will have to admit that there were times where I forgot which novel we were discussing in class as the story lines are so similar.
  Does anyone else have any opinions on this comparison between the two novels? Do you think Austen was only writing based off her own life because she knew nothing else? I mean just look at the book covers below, granted Austen does not have a say on the ways in which the covers of her books look but look at how publishing companies have chosen to depict the front covers. The images are almost identical in nature.

Works Cited
Google Images
Class Notes. April 9, 2014.

Pride and Prejudice: A Very Amiable Movie



I'll be the first to admit that the 2005 movie directed by Wright and starring Keira Knightly did not accurately portray the Jane Austen novel. And you can go on just about any website to find all of the inaccuracies of the movie rendition. However, I think that Wright managed to portray a few major themes from the novel very well. One of these themes is the constraints on marriage. 

Constraints on marriage are mentioned by various characters throughout the entire movie, just as they are in the novel. Mr. Bingley is at first hesitant to propose to Jane because of Mr. Darcy's insistence on avoiding the Bennetts, whom show little regard for decorum and propriety. But he is also swayed to delay his proposal because of Jane's lack of wealth. As we have discussed, these were important factors to consider in the marriage context of the early nineteenth century. Therefore, Mr. Bingely's hesitations, or rather, Mr. Darcy's hesitations on Bingley's behalf and his own, were very reasonable and rational ones. Marriage was a delicate matter to consider, and all factors needed to be regarded with utmost seriousness. 

And men are not the only ones shown considering the more practical aspects of marriage. Charlotte's out-lash at Lizzy over her marriage to Mr. Elliot also keeps close to the theme of marriage constraints. Charlotte who is neither pretty nor wealthy has few marriage prospects. So when Mr. Elliot offers his hand in marriage, she gladly accepts, for now she has security, protection, and in a way, more freedom. Love, in her mind, is not a requirement to be happy with her marriage. This is something inconceivable to Lizzy, but quite real and rational to Charlotte. Austen and Wright, with the case of Charlotte Lucas, provide the eye-opening view that marriage was a practical and economical matter in the nineteenth century, despite the wishful thinkings of women such as Lizzy. While Lizzy may have, in the end, received all that she ever wanted in marriage, she was one of the rare ones. 
Overall, I enjoyed Wright's movie. I feel that he did a decent job of portraying Mr. Darcy in the beginning as very proud, snobbish, and somber, and then, slowly throughout the movie, as a man conscientious to others' needs, loyal, and utterly devoted to and in love with Lizzy. He was like an onion, and as the movie progressed, the layers were peeled away to reveal the Darcy that we all are smitten with. I also enjoyed Lizzy's portrayal. Though decidedly more outspoken and defiant than the Austen character, Knightly makes Lizzy bold, headstrong, and intelligent, the kind of modern character many long to see in the nineteenth-century setting. I liked this more brash Elizabeth, and it made her interactions with Darcy all the more enticing. 
To conclude, though  you shouldn't watch this movie if you are expecting an accurate theatrical rendition of the Jane Austen novel, you should watch it to be provided with an idea of the whole marriage process in the nineteenth century, to see these peoples struggles, hopes and aspirations, and to grasp their opinions on love and matrimony. 

Jane Austen: Writing What You Know


For this week’s blog, I would like to further explore the parallels between Jane Austen’s life and her novels. Firstly, her life in the country, her education at home, the close friendship with her sister, and her brothers’ careers as military officers are all reflected in Pride and Prejudice, as well as her other novels, through her characters and settings. In addition, she made visits to a brother in London and to a brother who lived on a wealthy estate, while also moving to and living in Bath with her family for a time, all of which indicate settings or travel destinations in her characters’ stories. Like the female party of the Dashwood family in Sense and Sensibility, after Mr. Austen’s death, Jane, her sister, and mother were forced to relocate, dependent on her brothers’ generosity, and eventually living in a cottage provided by one of her brothers. Austen also fell in love with a man who was forced to marry for money elsewhere, while rejecting a proposal from another whom she respected, but was not in love with. This is obviously reflected through the way in which Austen uses her novels to critique the marriage system for its economic priorities over considerations of romantic love.  Finally, Mr. Austen encouraged Jane to write and even promoted her novels, which may indicate a close relationship between her and her father like that of the one between Elizabeth and Mr. Bennett in Pride and Prejudice. Altogether, Jane Austen’s personal biographical information has close ties to the plots, characters, and criticisms integral to her novels. Although Austen was said to have lived a “quiet life,” we can see that she charted the interactions between the middle class and the wealthier classes of society in her novels, as well as pursued settings of both town and country, which relates to her personal acquaintance with a diverse range of people and locales (within England itself). Such a strong link between Austen’s life and novels enables the reader to gain a vivid and somewhat realistic picture of English society at the time, and more importantly, an idea of Austen’s perception of her society’s norms.
Sources:
Chawton Cottage where Jane lived after her father's death.
 
 
 
 

Marianne and the emotional state

In the movie Sense and Sensibility, we have been introduced to the two sisters; Elinor and Marianne Dashwood.  Though the two are sisters, they are nearly polar opposites in their social and emotional thinking.  As we have witnessed in the movie,  Elinor takes a more conservative and rational approach to life, while Marianna seems to live by her heart and emotions.  But is there more to these two characters than what meets the eye?  According to Lianna Manukyan,  the differences between Elinor and Marianne represents emotion versus reason (Manukyan).  From the movie,  Marianne seemingly defies the aspect of rationality, while Elinor uses judgment and rational thinking to make decisions.  As Manukyan explains,  the concept of reason over emotion was a value attributed to the 18th century (Manukyan).  Jane Austen essentially captures the two ideas within the characters and plays them off of each other.  Marianne's portrayal allows her to go through many different phases so far in the movie.  Because of her emotional nature, she is more willing to allow her instincts to control her desires, and then act upon them rather than rationally calculating various outcomes.  Marianne's character is essential in explaining the aspect of emotion when compared to reason. Jane Austen's characters have made an impact on women's history.  And the character of Marianne allows the reader to understand the use of emotion in relation to reason throughout the novel. 

Source: http://web.calstatela.edu/faculty/jgarret/467/sample4-2.htm

Mrs. Bennett




While reading Pride and Prejudice I have come to the conclusion that Mrs. Bennett may be one of the main causes that the views on marriage (in regards to women) took an incredibly long time to change. Marriage is viewed as nothing more than monetary contract. A chance to gain wealth that would otherwise be unattainable in the present circumstances. Not knowing any other possible way for her daughters to gain wealth in life, Mrs. Bennett would stop at nothing to ensure that her daughters were married off to some rich man. When Bingley showed up in the story it was difficult to determine exactly who was more in love with him, the daughters or Mrs. Bennett. I can imagine dozens of sidebar conversations going on between Mrs. Bennett and Bingley, with Mrs. Bennett going on and on about wonderful her daughters are and that Bingley should marry them. I feel like she stepped over the line at the point when she sent Jane over to Bingley's house, knowing that Jane would ultimately get stuck there and have to stay. And then refusing to send the carriage to pick her up.

Clearly Mrs. Bennett has no plans on changing the ways that women are treated or how marriage is looked at. Continuing to attempt to send off her daughters to other men. As annoying as I find Mrs. Bennett,how terrible the situation is for her daughters, I can still understand why she does the things she does. Mrs. Bennett is simply a product of her era. To her understanding sending her daughters off to marry wealthy men is the only way that her daughters can thrive and live in this world. Considering that they can not inherit property or business. So in a sense Mrs. Bennett's actions can be seen as acts of love and concern for her children. But unfortunetly continuing with this line of actions will never gain women any progress. It is probably for the best then that Mrs. Bennett's line of thoughts fall out of traditional thinking.