10 April 2014

A Rational Creature?

(A photograph showing a first edition of Pride and Prejudice by Jane Austen.)

Since this week we are discussing all things Jane Austen, I decided to dive in to a specific idea that has been stirring in my head. This idea relates to Elizabeth Bennet and her supposed “break” from the mold of an ideal woman during eighteenth century England. I refer to her rather dramatic breakdowns in which she berates and blames herself for the situation when in reality it does not help her cause at all. One could argue that Austen does this intentionally to create drama in the story as well as make a more readily identifiable character out of Elizabeth. If she does not have these breakdowns, it is possible less women would relate to the heroine of the story. But by creating such dramatic breakdowns, not in line with the character of Elizabeth, Austen almost harms the character of her heroine by making her inconsistent.


Instead of being “a rational creature” Elizabeth loses herself to the very “foolishness”, she remarks that Kitty and Lydia possess. The reason I question this is a few instances that occur regularly throughout Pride and Prejudice. Two major instances of such breakdowns come to mind. One her breakdown following reading Darcy’s letter, of course some confusion is expected. The fact that she wanders around lost disbelieving for hours on end, and still refuses to believe for a day or two before realizing her flawed logic is extreme. Once she begins to accept the letter as true she still exclaims, “How despicably have I acted! I, who have prided myself on my discernment! I, who have valued myself on my abilities,” (Austen 177). Her exclamation does not end after this, confusion is acceptable, so is disbelief, yet it should not last for pages while she internally debates the situation. It comes across as overkill, at least to me personally. The second instance of such a breakdown is more extreme; it is when she realizes that Lydia has run off with Wickham. She blames herself for the whole thing, just because she did not divulge the secret of Wickham’s character she did not share. Elizabeth says, “When I consider, that I might have prevented it! I who knew what he was. Had I but explained some part of it only – some part of what I learnt, to my own family,” (Austen 231). God forbid she looks at the situation logically and recognizes that this behavior from her sister is expected, if it was not to be Wickham surely it would have been another. Or that she remembers that in fact she did tell someone about Wickham, she told Jane. So she cannot be blamed for the whole situation. All these instances of Elizabeth being dramatic seem contrived and places Elizabeth in a poor light.

09 April 2014

Peach pits and syphilis

Doing women's history is hard work--mostly because we want simple and quick answers . . . fast and easy. But as a historian trying to access "facts" to make an interpretation, this can be hindered by the myriad other poor interpretations that intermingle and disturb our vision of the past. I am intrigued by most topics for which I think there is misunderstanding--of course, Joan of Arc, witch-hunts, but also women's history. What makes for accurate history, and how do we know if we've found it?  In most cases, heading to the primary source and records will make for a more accurate recovery of the past; at least, I trust the sources more than I do many modern accounts.

This was made more clear to me as we discussed the theme of women and art in class, and examined an article by Carolyn P. Murphy on Properzia d'Rossia, sculptor from Bologna and amazing peach pit carver (I may have to day trip to Florence to view this at the Pitti Palace in June--get it? . . . pits at the Pitti palace). In class we all were struck by the suggestion that she died in a "syphilitic hospital"--but in looking this over, it seems difficult to justify this assumption (more research needed of course). I would like to know more about the start of the assumption and what century/decade is responsible for it. I was able to find some materials on Properzia, though there is not too much. First, I noticed Murphy used the same reference in her 1996 dissertation  (footnote 3; http://discovery.ucl.ac.uk/1349274/1/339172_vol1.pdf. Then I read Vasari's account for evidence (thanks to Allison for pointing out the reference to her husband, also fascinating and frequently overlooked). In The Lives of the Artist, sixteenth-century artist and art historian Vasari writes that "she was buried at the Ospedale della Morte", or the Hospital of Death. Syphilis arrived in Bologna around 1495, per an article by S. Sabbatani, and ravaged the city; however, Properzia would have been about five years old at that point. The syphilis hospital was known as the Ospedale della San Giobbe, which was in existence until 1798. There were also 2 other hospitals--the hospital of life and the hospital of death. Vasari tells us she was buried at the hospital of death--and that's it. But this is hardly conclusive to anything. The Hospital of Death was where one went to die--like a hospice, if there was little money. Most would have been cared for by family before going there. I wonder if Vasari's notion that she was lovestruck may have influenced her interpretation as a sexual woman? If so, she would not be the first woman who was viewed through a gendered lens.

Here's some tips, as we head forward into research-land:

1.  Beware the book being touted as a best-seller, or retranslated and republished, and it has to do with women's history and sex. Case in point: The Birth of the Salons, the book discussed last week on the blog.  Sex sells.  To suggest that salons were dens of iniquity seems far-fetched. The problem is in the interpretation of what is a salon. If you have images of movies set in the 18th century in your head (wigs, low cut dresses, etc.), frequently set at Versailles, those are not salons; those are courts, and full of palace intrigue, of course.

2. Many books on women--such as those on the Tudor monarchy--reinterpret history incorrectly and assume that scandalous accusations must be true. This applies to many such as  Anne Boleyn, Eleanor of Aquitaine, and Elizabeth I.

3.  Beware the biography. Many biographies of women were completed before there was a strong idea of gender as a cultural construct that shapes actions and ideas. If you have biographies that go from birth to death without gender analysis, it probably does not do justice to the historical figure.

This is not all bad news. Where there is bad history, there can be good history. It takes some effort, reflection, and usually an analysis that puts women front and center.






Was Jane Austen a Feminist?

      


             Jane Austen’s novels, Pride and Prejudice and Sense and Sensibility, seem to have dual reputations among modern audiences. If taken at face value, many readers view the stories to be romantic and idealistic with male heroes and damsels in distress, truly a peek into a time long passed where morals and manners meant everything. On the contrary, when I first read the book a few years ago, I did not enjoy it because it reveals the many difficulties women faced at the turn of the nineteenth century. I felt sorry for Elizabeth because she is an intellectual trapped in a world where most women constantly chattered about frivolous things and I was annoyed by Mrs. Bennet’s scheming to get her daughters married at any cost. Both of these reputations of Pride and Prejudice do not delve into the subversive message which Austen was portraying in her writing outlet. It might have been common for a female author to write about marriage in the nineteenth century; however Austen brings something unique to the table.
                In our discussions about Pride and Prejudice in the “History of European Women” and another class I took earlier, “Women Writers,” I found that my first perception of this novel was entirely wrong. As Dr. Wolbrink discussed today, Jane Austen not only commented on the problems with the marriage system and inheritance laws in her writing, she critiqued them and revealed their absurdities. She set her commentary within a story which could be taken at face value or which could reveal a subversive message about the plight of women and their lack of rights. 
             While Austen did want to show how little rights women had, she also highlighted their agency. For example, the characters of Jane in Pride and Prejudice and Marianne in Sense and Sensibility show how women used their “weaknesses” in their favor. Recall the scene where Marianne falls and hurts her ankle. She is not hysterical or in terrible pain, but she asks her younger sister to go tell her mother to send someone to help her walk back. Along comes Willoughby and saves the day, and for several days she uses this incident to gain sympathy from two male suitors while her mother and sisters play along. Drawing parallels, the character of Jane in Pride and Prejudice also uses an illness to her advantage (with the scheming of her mother). After catching a cold along the way to visit the Bingley sisters, she is asked to stay until she had recovered. Although she originally writes her family that she just has a headache and a sore throat, everyone seems to worry excessively about her. It seems that everyone is happy she is sick (especially Mrs. Bennet) because it gets Mr. Bingley’s sympathy and he is more likely to fall for her. Both of these examples seem to show women’s weaknesses, but if analyzed closely it is evident that Austen is showing how women played a role and worked around obstacles in a male biased society to try to control who they married.
                Because I feel that there are feminist themes in these two works of Austen, I researched what the common consensus was about whether she is considered a feminist or not. Interestingly there is a current debate which was most recently revived with the British printing Jane Austen’s portrait on their money last year. Beulah Devaney urges her audience to “stop calling Jane Austen a feminist” in her article in the Huffington Post. Devaney supports her argument by offering that feminism is a loaded and often misunderstood word that should not be used lightly; she stated that “Saying you're a feminist is to say that you believe that most women are oppressed, that the white, male privilege enjoyed by most of the people who hold power in this country should be overthrown.” I think that although Austen did not directly call for change, her stories reveal that she would probably agree with this modern definition of feminist. Oppositely, Devaney argues that it takes power away from the word because it calls into question what should qualify as active feminism and really there is no purpose for labeling people from the far past as feminists. I understand Devaney’s argument in the context of the modern women’s movement, but in the perspective of a historian I completely disagree. One thing that a women’s history class shows is that women have long been active in furthering their own progress. Jane Austen may not have known what a feminist was but she wrote with purpose. Why is there any harm in grouping her with other famous female writers such as Christine de Pisan? To me, it only highlights how many women across several centuries added to the women’s debate and ultimately the movement for change. 

                Jane Austen wrote from her own experiences as obvious in the many parallels with her personal life and her stories. Her novels were not meant only for entertainment but they give insight into the lives of women and the pressures of nineteenth century society. I now have a new perspective and respect for Elizabeth Bennet's character because as Dr. Wolbrink brought up in class today, she was the “new type” of woman which Austen seemed to say should be a role model for women. Between the Bennet sisters, as well as the Dashwood sisters, Austen showed the many types of women and paths women could take. This new educated “creature of reason” who critiqued marriage and refused to marry Mr. Collins to secure her families future showcased the way women were using their own agency to slowly make change in their world. 

Sources: 

      Leach, Sydney. "Jane Austen: A Feminist Icon?" Crisis Magazine. August 2013. http://www.crisismagazine.com/2013/jane-austen-a-feminist-icon. 

      Devaney, Beulah. "Why We Need to Stop Calling Jane Austen a Feminist." Huffington Post. October 2013. http://www.huffingtonpost.co.uk/beulah-maud-devaney/jane-austen-feminism_b_4177203.html.
        

03 April 2014

Elisabetta Caminer Turra


Within the topics addressed in class this week, I chose to delve further into women as writers in Europe, specifically through the example of Elisabetta Caminer Turra. Wiesner-Hanks classifies Turra as one of several Italian women who “spread Enlightenment ideas and argued for women’s learning in journals as well as salons” (167). Specifically, Turra “oversaw a publishing house and founded several journals,” arguing for women to further their education by reading intellectual information rather than fashion magazines of the day (167). A Venetian woman in the 18th century, Turra was, other than a publisher, a journalist and translator, even active in debates of the Enlightenment. In addition, she also directed some of the plays she translated. She was married, but her marriage obviously did not interfere with her ability to pursue an active and public life. Altogether, Turra represents the idea of women who were able to find agency in the midst of an entrenched Enlightenment viewpoint of women, one that was frequently negative, at times, theoretically encouraging of the education of women, yet ultimately rather inactive at changing women’s education or position in society. In addition, Turra exemplifies a certain pattern in history of the way in which women believe women should negate ideas of patriarchy. Turra’s recommendation that women should abandon trivial magazines in favor of educational reading brings to mind Christine de Pizan’s standard of virtuous women as the best way through which to eliminate patriarchal portrayals of women in a negative light. True, Pizan and Turra’s arguments are different, Pizan’s one of virtue and Turra’s one of intellect, but the two are aimed at the same objective: women embodying certain characteristics and thus, changing perceptions.  I wonder if such a strategy is effective or if it leads more so to criticism of women by women and thus, provides patriarchy with more “fuel for the fire,” a fire of negative views on women?
Sources:
Wiesner-Hanks, Merry E. Women and Gender in Early Modern Europe. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2008.
 
 

18th Century Paris Salons: An Elite Market of Prostitution?

  Earlier this week we discussed the role of salons during the 18th century. Salons were one of the settings in which women could have control over the direction of conversations and choose who to invite and who not to. Salons were held by upper, middle-class or noblewomen only and would take place in the woman's home (Notes). It can be argued that within salons women truly advanced in knowledge and I would argue even gained recognition. Salons were "by invitation only" events and the elite in society wanted to be invited due to the statuses of the salons. These were not simply meetings where women gathered to gossip about the latest dress fashions but were educational centers in which women could have some say.
  The New York Times article "Birth of the Salon" written by Alan Riding presents a new aspect about salons that I had not previously thought of. Riding admits that women did gain knowledge from the conversations held in salons but he also presents the idea that women also gained experience in the art of seduction. According to Riding, "Women honed the skills of politesse, conversation, writing, appearance and, yes, seduction" (NYTimes.com 1). Upon reading this article I could not help but wonder if the conversational aspect of salons was a cover-up to the underlying purpose of appealing to men of elite and wealthy social standing? Were salons a way for women to "market" themselves, almost like an elite form of prostitution? (Similar to the ways of Venetian courtesans). Riding writes, "Men too were drawn to the salons - and not only because mistresses could be found and exchanged there, drawn from the nobility's cleverest and most beautiful women" (NYTimes.com 1). 'Exchanged there?' Could this give a whole new meaning to the idea of salons?
   Dr. Wolbrink discussed in class that women may have actually had a very limited role in the actual conversational aspects of the salons, Riding seems to be hinting at the same idea as well. As historians we should view salons as a step in the advancement of women in society. Finally women were not only seen as decorative objects or "arm candy"; the idea that women actually had the ability to retain more knowledge than just needlework was on the verge of acceptance. However, do the fact that men were also invited to the salons, and usually outnumbered the female guests, what was the real purpose of salons? Were women trying to prove the point that they too could keep up in political debates just as well as the men? Or were the salons just an extension of the limitations women have always faced-beauty before brains? Or were women playing to their advantage; using their beauty to lure men in and actively engage in political debates? 

How many women do you see in the following images?

Works Cited
Riding, Alan. "Birth of the Salon." New York Times. Published November 20, 2005.http://www.nytimes.com/2005/11/20/books/review/20riding.html?_r=0.
Images from Google.

Mary Wollstonecraft



After Wednesday's discussion of women and the Enlightenment,  I have decided to research more about women during this time and their views toward women's rights.  Mary Wollstonecraft's,  A Vindication of the Rights of Women, provides one example of the views of women.  Wollstonecraft studied moral and political theories and applied this to her writing.  She posed the question of 'why women were inferior to men?'  and argued against popular male writers of the time.  In Wollstonecraft's Vindication of the Rights of Women, she mentions the views of Rousseau and argues his ideals.  Wollstonecraft states, "Who ever drew a more exalted female character than Rousseau?  Though in the lump he constantly endeavoured to degrade the sex" (CP 178).  Wollstonecraft uses attacks on writers such as Rousseau in order to further her arguments.  Her views of women's rights paved the way for other politically savvy women.  In some respects, Wollstonecraft's writing compares to that of Olympe de Gouges because of their views that women should be allowed the same inalienable rights of men.  Wollstonecraft's take on women is often a radical and "in your face" interpretation that has left a lasting impact on readers throughout this period. 




Sources:

http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/wollstonecraft/

Women's History Coursepacket, Compiled by Dr. Wolbrink

Olympe de Gouges



Olympe de Gouges' Declaration of the Rights of Woman provides an interesting view on how women in the Enlightenment and French Revolution viewed one another. Something that I find really interesting in her writing is her sharpness towards other women. While much of what we have been reading has placed the blame of female subjugation on man, Olympe de Gouges takes this a step further and also places blame on women, as can be seen in the postscript: "Women have done more harm than good" (Declaration of the Rights of Woman). In this proclamation, she is referencing women in the old regime (the monarchy), specifically the nobility. Her contempt to such women is obvious with the statement: "A woman only had to be beautiful and amiable; when she possessed these two advantages, she saw a hundred fortunes at her feet. . . The most indecent woman could make herself respectable with gold" (Postscript Declaration on the Rights of Woman). Considering her background as a self-educated butcher's daughter, it is easy to see where this resentment could have arisen from. Women who had more opportunities than she did were, in her opinion, wasting them. She then chastises these women for their relative inactivity during the Revolution and even probably the Enlightenment with statements such as: "Oh women! Women, when will you cease to be blind? What advantages have you gathered in the Revolution?" (Postscript Declaration of the Rights of Woman). And she finally urges them to take matters into their own hands: "Women, wake up; the tocsin of reason sounds throughout the universe; recognize your rights" (Postscript Declaration of the Rights of Woman). As we discussed in class, her declaration is riddled with enlightened phrases, such as universe, nature, and reason. 

            I think what I like most about Olympe de Gouges is her ability to speak her mind, and her desire not only to criticize men, but also women. I agree with her sentiment that women were partially responsible for not obtaining the equality they desired. While we might consider this as a hindrance in gaining support from her female peers, it may have been seen as a much needed wake-up call for these women. Though there is some debate about whether Olympe de Gouges can be considered a full feminist, by the standards stated in class – recognizing the inequality between genders and then trying to rectify it – she certainly qualifies in my opinion.  

Source Used: http://chnm.gmu.edu/revolution/d/293/